I've just went through and evaluated my feedback from the crit today, the format was where the groups were split in 2, and we walked around the room and left written feedback for each other. Also, we were told to leave 3 questions for the assessor to have an idea of what to write, mine were:
Q1. The photograph of stationary is intended to be 'life size', do you think customers would benefit from getting a good idea of size when buying?'
Q2. Do you think the Red Minimal Design could benefit from some kind of embossing or de-bossing effect on the type?
Q3. Is the vector artwork design effective at all? (I'm not convinced).
Again, I've found this process useful, when lots of other peoples individual opinions start building up, you know you need to react to it. I'll quickly go through the bits I've found particularly helpful:
Most people generally found the vector design confusing and a little hard to distinguish, I agree with them. However others said they quite liked it, one person even said it was their favourite. If I'm honest I'll probably not take that one any further.
A lot of people agreed that any kind of embossing effect on the red designs would ruin it, and the simplicity of it would be forfeited, also that it would be a wasted process as the paper is under glass, therefore making It unnecessarily expensive.
An interesting point that I found was that somebody commented about Ion's newest work on Behancé, relating it to my vector design and how there were elements of it with my work. This was were I got my original inspiration from so it's quite interesting to come full circle.
Many people liked the idea of the life-sized stationary as a size reference, however they thought the stationary itself was dull. I did originally plan to use other things, perhaps food? Others thought it was a nice touch but unnecessary, people generally are aware of what size frame they want when they are looking for one.
Regarding the red minimal designs, a strong majority of people believed it to be the most visually strong, and again I agree. This is probably the one I will develop, but I also want to experiment with photography first. Someone had a nice idea of perhaps overlaying a photograph in low opacity or with a layer blend over the design, this is something I will definitely try.
All in all a successful critique I think.